Mineral Resources Minister, Gwede Mantashe, has, once again, publicly defended the role of coal in South Africa's energy mix. He has also brought into stark reality the costs of producing electricity from nuclear, coal, and renewable energy. Minister Mantashe has highlighted that Eskom generates electricity at its Koeberg Nuclear Plant for approximately R0.40 per unit, for approximately R0.80 a unit at the coal-fired power plants but that it was purchasing renewable energy from independent power producers at approximately R2.20 a unit.


While renewable energy is critical to a sustainable future, coal-fired power stations are here for the foreseeable future.

One of the things that struck me on a recent business trip to Europe was the significant increase in the number of electric vehicles on the roads since my last trip. In one of the cities, almost every taxi was an electric vehicle, and I took the opportunity to engage with the drivers on their views in relation to electric vehicles. There seemed to be a strong sense of pride that electric vehicles were being used and, almost exclusively. The reasons given for the use of electric vehicles were environmental considerations and changing regulations in Europe.

The dynamic of the conversation did, however, change when I posed the question regarding the source of the electricity for charging the electric vehicles, and while I should not generalise, for the purposes of this article, it certainly seemed that there is a disconnect between perceptions of the benefits associated with the use of electric vehicles, and what it takes to charge those vehicles. This disconnect is probably even more significant in South Africa with its strong dependence on coal-fired generation of electricity. While South Africa's renewable energy programmes are limping along, South Africans will, in my view, continue to rely on electricity generated from coal-fired power stations for the foreseeable future.

Both thermal coal and coking coal have played a significant role in the first, second and third industrial revolutions. In the first industrial revolution, water and steam power replaced human and animal power, while in the second industrial revolution, electricity, the internal combustion engine, aeroplanes, telephony, vehicles, radio and mass production featured. In the third industrial revolution, automation was the key defining feature based on electronics, the establishment of the internet, and the use of IT solutions to further enhance mass production through automation. South Africa's mining industry, including the coal mining industry, has often been at the forefront of innovation, with numerous domestic inventions providing global solutions. More recently, the South African mining industry has focused on automation, with digitisation playing a key role in automation of several exploration and extractive systems.

There have been a number of drivers which have forced the South African mining industry to focus on mechanisation in the interim, and ultimately, on automation. These drivers include the high costs associated with mining operations. While there have been significant increases in the costs of employment, which has been on an expected trajectory, relatively recent costing of the risk associated with policy and regulatory uncertainty is playing a more substantial role in high mining costs. These factors are making inevitable the shift from digitisation, the primary feature of the third industrial revolution, to systems based on a combination of connected technologies. This shift to the connectivity and combination of technologies is the key feature of the fourth industrial revolution, and it is essential for the South African coal mining industry to fully appreciate the changing environment, and to innovate, as part of the cycle of continuous improvement.

While there is still extensive debate on what the fourth industrial revolution means, and the consequences of block chain payment platforms, innovation is likely to be substantially based on the Internet of Things (IoT). With the historical focus (third industrial revolution) on information technology and digitisation around people and IT processes communicating, the IoT focuses on equipment and machines communicating with one another on a continuous, real-time basis. This concept is unlikely to be new to South Africa's mining industry, including the coal mining industry, which has focused on real-time monitoring of machines and equipment for production purposes for some time. However, what will be a major disruptor, in future, is the scale of the connectivity and levels of communication between equipment and machines. There is also likely to be a shift, particularly in relation to original equipment manufacturers, from only providing machines, to providing a fully managed solution to the mining industry. Equipment and machines that are supplied by original equipment manufacturers as products will form part of a network, allowing not only real-time monitoring but also management and adjustment to optimise production levels.

The IoT is also likely to have a significant impact on one of the most important elements, namely healthy and safe production. The ability to monitor, manage, and identify what has gone wrong is likely to improve health and safety at South African mines.

While there is likely to be robust debate on the fourth industrial revolution and the IoT, including fears that society will be roboticised, IoT will, in my view, be the single most significant disruptor of the South African coal mining industry in the foreseeable future, and the reality is that several of the supporting platforms are already in place. These include cloud-based storage and analytics, low-energy wide area networks, and 5-G cellular.

With the advantages of IoT, there are, of course, a number of challenges including the vast amount of data that will be produced, which will need careful management, not only in relation to its efficient use but also in terms of compliance with legal requirements on privacy and data storage protection. Perhaps, however, one of the most significant impacts and challenges could be on employees. The South African mining industry is again facing large scale dismissals and perhaps fears of the IoT and its consequences may be justified. Importantly, the opportunities created by the IoT are widespread, with a strong emphasis on a strong skills base. In this context, the mining industry would need to review its training programmes and its skills investment carefully.

It certainly seems that the coal mining industry, at least in South Africa, is here to stay, and that it will be significantly disrupted by the fourth industrial revolution and the IoT.

Beech is a Partner and Head of Mining with Hogan Lovells (South Africa).